Read The Book, Please

Read The Book, Please

127
103
24
Post Comments
127
103
24
11 comments
Sort by:

REGISTER | You need to login or register before you can comment.

TiboltDaluka 0 karmaJuly 2013
Because of course every movie has to be identical to the book... How has this left the votes page!?
SukhberS +1 karmaJuly 2013
Are you talking about their family cat?
emily98531 +2 karmaJuly 2013
If you judge the movie based on the book, you're only setting yourself up for disappointment. His parents were the most important part and the others really weren't needed.
HyperSquad452 +2 karmaJuly 2013
How about you don't judge a movie based on the book? It isn't called "harry potter the book the movie" It's called "harry potter the movie" It already took them like 2 or 3 years to make each film. You really wanna triple how long each took? They'd be 30yrs old playing kids. let the - karma flow!
Kaiba 0 karmaJuly 2013
It's one of the few things the movies changed that bugs me. The vast majority of changes they made I'm fine with. There's many changes that I prefer to what we got in the books.Attractive Hermione? Yes please. No stupid wizard hats on everybody? Thank you, zombie Jesus. "You're a wizard, Harry" rather than "Harry, you're a wizard"? It feels like the book got it wrong every time I read that line.So yeah, please calm yourself. This is one of the very few changes I would call for.
HyperSquad452 0 karmaJuly 2013
Understandable. However, I stand by what I said. There's a reason they write a script for the movies rather than just using the book as the script. The movies did not reference the importance as much so it did not make as much sense within the story the movies were telling to have it. You have to remember, The books and movies tell two different stories. Think of it like the different gospels in the bible. They all tell the same basic story but each has a slightly different interpretation and emphasize different details.
Kaiba 0 karmaJuly 2013
Yes, Harry Potter is comparable to religion, I agree.
HyperSquad452 0 karmaJuly 2013
Hah. Let's not get into THAT debate right now. I've gotten enough negative karama for expressing my opinions. Think of it more as a manner of story telling rather than religion.
LeviOsaNotLeviosA +1 karmaJuly 2013
It's always really bugged me as well! It was much more touching in the book.
Charlatan [m] +4 karmaJuly 2013
What a genuinely wanky title you've got going on there.
Kaiba -1 karmaJuly 2013
This comment has been deleted.